About a year after the Onteora Central School Board’s decision to close Woodstock Elementary School in 2028, a group of parents and educators are now proposing a tuition-free elementary charter school to open in the Woodstock area.
The proposed Woodstock Community Charter School of the Catskills would serve K-2 students in Onteora, Saugerties, Kingston, and other nearby school districts like New Paltz, according to Tansy Michaud, a graphic designer and one of the parents behind the proposal.
Charter schools are tuition-free public schools that operate independently of local school districts and are governed by their own nonprofit boards of trustees. They have more flexibility over their educational programs and school policies but must meet state academic standards and testing requirements. They operate under state-approved agreements, called charters, that set performance requirements. Families apply for admission; if applications exceed available seats, schools must hold a lottery.
The organizers must submit a notice of intent to apply to the SUNY Charter Schools Institute, a state authorizer of charter schools, by February and a formal application by April 2027, Michaud said.
As part of the application process, the organizers are conducting initial outreach via an interest form and community survey to gauge interest among families, and must perform an analysis of the funding and enrollment impacts to the surrounding school districts, Michaud said.
In the first two weeks of public outreach, which the group began in November, at least 70 families with 85 children filled out the group’s nonbinding enrollment interest form, Michaud said. The school is not yet at the stage of recruiting teachers, Michaud said, although some have also expressed interest.
Pending interest and enrollment, the school would add an additional grade each year up to fifth grade, Michaud said. The school would compete with Onteora’s planned expansion of Bennett Elementary into a districtwide K-5 school as it transitions to a centralized K-12 campus in Boiceville by 2028.
Michaud is one of many parents who advocated against Woodstock Elementary’s closure and planned district consolidation last year.
“A year ago, we didn’t set out wanting to start a school. Actually, we set out trying to save one,” said Michaud, whose 3-year-old daughter will be starting kindergarten in 2028.
There is demand for a tuition-free schooling option among parents considering homeschooling and private school options, or moving districts altogether, as alternatives to sending their kids to Bennett, Michaud said.
“People want to have their kids in a school that is closer to their community where they live, especially the youngest learners in elementary school,” Michaud said. “Many families, for that reason, are indicating that they might not continue to Bennett.”
The proposed charter school would follow an arts-integrated, nature-based, and community-focused curriculum adherent to New York State Learning Standards, according to founding member Susan Paynter.
Paynter, who also serves as chair of the Woodstock Environmental Commission, has previously been involved in starting two K-8 charter schools that are still operating.
One school, Unity Charter School in Morristown, New Jersey, was founded in 1998, growing from 60 students to around 250 students, Paynter said. The other, Ridge and Valley Charter School in Blairstown, New Jersey, opened in 2004 and has 134 students.
Organizers have not yet determined a location for the school, but it would be located in Woodstock, Michaud said.
“The school located in Woodstock could serve many of the families who are in that developing public school desert area that, after Woodstock (Elementary) closes, won’t have a public elementary school between Saugerties, Kingston and Boiceville,” she said.
The closure of Woodstock Elementary is part of a national trend of public schools shuttering due to declining enrollment, low birth rates, and more school choice. The New York Times reported on Nov. 17 that more than 100 schools nationwide have been slated for closure or consolidation since last year.
The Onteora Central School District has had about a 50% decrease in enrollment over the last 20 years, according to New York State Education Department data, falling from 2,068 students in 2005 to 1,085 students in 2025.
Superintendent Victoria McLaren said the proposed charter school would put additional pressure on the district’s already-strained budget.
Under New York state law, charter schools are directly funded by students’ home districts at a per-pupil rate. The charter school basic tuition rate for Onteora is $21,994 per pupil for 2026-27, according to the state Education Department. For Kingston City School District, the rate is $21,078 per pupil. Saugerties Central would pay $15,996.
The proposed school would receive funding from any nearby districts whose students attend the school. A student’s home district would also be required to provide transportation for eligible students who live within 15 miles of the school.
“The diversion of funds from all of these school districts will undoubtedly negatively impact the programs that we are able to provide to students in our buildings,” McLaren said.
The school would be governed by an independent board of trustees, which has yet to be formed, Michaud said. Its charter application and ongoing school performance would be evaluated by SUNY, Michaud said.
The organizers of the proposed school will be holding an information session over Zoom after Thanksgiving, with a date to be determined, and an in-person session at the Woodstock Library on Dec. 3 from 10:30 to 11:30 a.m.
Isabella Schoonover is a staff reporter for The Overlook covering Woodstock, Saugerties, Hurley, and surrounding Ulster County communities. Send correspondence to isabella@theoverlooknews.com.



