Voters endorsed a $41.9 million capital plan Wednesday to overhaul the Onteora Central School District’s Boiceville campus and prepare it to serve all students from kindergarten through 12th grade by 2028. The approval sweeps aside months of objections from residents who argued the price tag was too high and urged the district to keep Woodstock Elementary School open.
Preliminary results show Proposition 1 passed 718–399 and Proposition 2 passed 764–347, advancing a scaled-down facilities plan that district leaders say will modernize aging buildings, support the move to a single K–12 campus, and avoid any increase to the tax levy.
The vote capped a long public debate over class configuration at Bennett Elementary, the scope of long-deferred infrastructure repairs, and the district’s three-year consolidation timeline. Despite a last-minute petition filed by two residents seeking to halt the election, the State Education Department declined to intervene, allowing the vote to proceed as scheduled.
With the propositions approved, the district will now begin developing final architectural plans for submission to the State Education Department and start planning for all K–5 students to come together at Bennett Elementary on the Boiceville campus in fall 2028.
Proposition 1: Bennett to Become a K–5 School
The approval of Proposition 1 means Bennett Elementary will become the districtwide K–5 school, retaining fifth graders with younger students. The $26.9 million project includes eight new classrooms, an expanded library and art room, a secure entrance, exterior-access restrooms, and multiple mechanical and drainage upgrades.
Superintendent Victoria McLaren said the vote provides clarity after months of emotional discussion.
“If Proposition 1 did not pass, we would have moved fifth grade into the middle school. Now we can plan for K–5 together at Bennett,” McLaren said Tuesday before the preliminary results were announced. “This community has shown an incredible willingness to engage, ask questions, and think about the long-term.”
District officials emphasize that all students will be on the Boiceville campus by September 2028 when Woodstock Elementary will officially close, regardless of the vote, a decision the Board unanimously made in October. Savings produced by consolidating operations, they say, will fully offset the bond costs.
Proposition 2: Infrastructure Improvements Move Forward
Proposition 2’s approval authorizes $15 million in districtwide repairs and upgrades, including modern windows and lighting at Bennett, improved and soundproofed music rooms, drainage work on athletic fields, resurfacing of the track, and upgrades to science labs and the nurse’s suite.
No borrowing is required, and the district will draw from capital reserves, cash on hand, and state building aid.
Next Steps
With both propositions approved, design work will begin immediately, followed by state review and a competitive bidding process. Construction is expected to proceed in phases aligned with the district’s three-year consolidation timeline. Results are set to be certified on Dec. 16.
District leaders acknowledged the emotional and often contentious months leading up to the vote.
“Tonight’s vote marks the end of a difficult chapter,” the district said in a statement. “We are deeply grateful to every voter who participated and to every community member who engaged in this difficult conversation with care. We know this journey has not been easy, and we honor the emotions, hopes, and concerns that have shaped it.”
Superintendent McLaren echoed that sentiment, noting the depth of community involvement throughout the process.
“I have learned that this community has amazing capacity for empathy,” McLaren said. “They may agree or they may not agree, but I am glad they came out and had the conversations with us.”
Noah Eckstein is the editor-in-chief of The Overlook. Send correspondence to noah@theoverlooknews.com.



