Tannersville Mayor Lee McGunnigle speaks at a Village Board planning session on Nov. 19. Photo by Connor Greco/The Overlook.

Tannersville Mayor Lee McGunnigle, who has led the village on-and-off since 1994, won’t seek reelection in March. He said he “cannot handle the weight” of the village’s increasingly bitter politics. 

McGunnigle, 67, made the decision public at a Village Board planning session on Thursday, Nov. 19, shortly after an audience member called him a “coward” for not taking public comment. New York’s Open Meetings Law doesn’t require public bodies to hear from the public. 

“I’m usually a fighter and I can handle it,” he said. “I’ve loved the work for a lot of years. But the new political environment for local elected officials? I think people should rethink, get a little spiritual growth, go to church, figure out how to treat your neighbors.”

After McGunnigle spoke, Deputy Mayor George Kelly, a village trustee since 2024, said he’d run for mayor on the Republican line. 

The election in Tannersville, a village of about 570 people in the town of Hunter, is March 16. 

McGunnigle has lived in the village since the mid-1980s. He was most recently elected in 2025 on the unaffiliated “Friends of Tannersville” line. He said officials increasingly take abuse from the public, including online. 

“I speak for all elected officials that we are not whipping posts for the public,” he said. “We oftentimes get treated like it, we’re spoken about on social media, and people think it’s okay. I don’t think it’s okay. It’s only put a dark cloud over my community.”

McGunnigle’s decision comes amid accusations that he has a conflict of interest involving a building permit issued for a short-term rental at 44 Hill St. Neighbors have argued the building doesn’t meet the village’s zoning law, which is meant to keep new construction in line with surrounding homes. 

The village Zoning Board of Appeals issued a stop work order for the building in October and held a public hearing on the property on Nov. 6. The proposal was expected to be discussed at the Village Board’s Nov. 19 meeting but wasn’t on the final agenda.

In a Nov. 19 letter to the board, Hill Street resident Greg Lubow said McGunnigle had a “working relationship” with the applicant’s brother, and said McGunnigle had “private meetings” with the developer and met with the village’s code enforcement officer “on behalf of the developer.” 

McGunnigle rejected the accusations. 

“There have been claims that I have recently reviewed cases where I have personal and financial relationships with the applicant, which are so false,” he said. “I know you can take cheap shots and slander public officials, usually without recourse, and I just want to set the record straight that I have never done that, period.”

“I understand the law,” McGunnigle said. “I’ve been in office for 30 years.”

Kelly, 64, was elected to the Village Board in 2024. He thanked McGunnigle for his tenure as mayor, and said he didn’t mind being the “whipping boy for the public.”

“There is an opportunity for a guy like me, who’s worked hard as a trustee, who loves his community,” Kelly said. “I love my neighbors. I think political discourse can get ugly, but that’s the way it goes. 

“I can take the heat, and there you go,” he said. 

McGunnigle said he would “do his best” to finish out his term. 

“I urge people to get involved in public service,” he said. “I also urge the public to try to give them a little respect, because this is not Republicans against Democrats. This is neighbor against neighbor.”

Connor Greco is a staff reporter for The Overlook covering Windham, Hunter, and surrounding Greene County communities. Send correspondence to connor@theoverlooknews.com.


"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Have a tip for a story or an issue in your community? See something happening we should know about? Let us know!

Connor Greco is a lifelong resident of Greene County, graduating from Cairo-Durham High School in 2019. He started his reporting career at the State University of New York at Albany, where he studied journalism...