If you could have dinner with any journalist—past or present—who would it be and why? 

Jacqueline Kellachan: I can’t choose just one! I’d love to have dinner with Nikole Hannah-Jones. “The 1619 Project” was a brilliant, multi-media undertaking that challenged traditional narratives about slavery and sparked a national conversation. I’d love to ask her how that project first took shape.

Two other journalists I’ve been fortunate to meet through The Golden Notebook are Linda Villarosa and Masha Gessen. Villarosa’s reporting on the intersection of maternal health and social justice has been transformative, reshaping conversations around racial disparities in healthcare. And Gessen’s fearless coverage of authoritarianism, repression, and LGBTQ rights is unparalleled.

Scott Widmeyer: There are quite a few. One would be the late David Broder of The Washington Post. In his time, he was the dean of political reporting—balanced, insightful, and widely respected. Politicians on both sides sought him out to communicate their messages, and for more than 50 years, he covered presidential politics with integrity. I deeply admired his work.

Another dinner companion would be the late Cokie Roberts of NPR and ABC. She was a trailblazer, and through her reporting, she helped inspire more women to run for office. I miss her dearly. I’m fortunate to still work with her husband, Steve Roberts, who teaches at the School of Media & Public Affairs at The George Washington University, where I serve as chair of its National Council.

Looking ahead, what kind of impact do you want The Overlook to have on Hunter, Hurley, Saugerties, Shandaken, Olive, and Woodstock? 

Scott Widmeyer: So much is at stake in today’s world. My hope is that The Overlook will be a platform, a bridge, so to speak, to bring people together. Our mission is to be a voice for all and to go the extra mile in giving all sides room to tell their story. We will shine a light on what’s working and what’s not working in our communities. And, we will celebrate the many folks in our communities who are doing the good deeds and lending a hand to lift up life in our towns. At the same time, The Overlook must be a watchdog. We must investigate. We must probe, we must listen, and we must fully understand an issue before reporting on it. Like many Americans, I am deeply concerned about the bias that we too frequently observe in today’s media and the one-sided coverage that plays out particularly on cable news. My goal for The Overlook is that we can be more of a tent and include many perspectives around local, state, and global issues. We will never be able to come together if the path one takes is via a silo.

Jacqueline Kellachan: The first question I think of is what is a way to measure impact? There are some ways that are obvious – like a news story results in an elected official investigating and acting on an issue. That would be a great outcome of the journalism in The Overlook. But there are other ways where impact is less obvious: being a trusted source of news for these towns, keeping residents informed and mobilizing them to engage in the community in some way, or even taking political action. That is the kind of impact I hope to have. But I also hope that people will feel more connected to their own community as well as all the other towns in the Overlook Region. We all have so much in common in the joy of living in such a beautiful place. I look forward to The Overlook asking the communities this exact question about impact in a year or so.

Why did you choose the nonprofit model, and how do you envision building sustainable support for this work? 

Jacqueline Kellachan: The traditional for-profit journalism model has failed, permanently disrupted by technology and private equity. When Scott Widmeyer and I began discussing a local newspaper, we looked at other news start-ups and how they were structured. Many were adopting the nonprofit model, which prioritizes the public interest and relies on diverse revenue streams. For The Overlook to be sustainable, we will draw from multiple sources—advertising, foundation grants, and both small and large individual donations. I also believe public funding can play a role. For example, in 2024, New York State passed a bill offering tax credits to support community journalism, demonstrating how government support can help sustain local news.

Scott Widmeyer: We truly hope the local community will engage with The Overlook in many ways—whether as readers, contributors, or supporters through tax-deductible donations.

As long as we provide coverage that is unbiased, thorough, timely, and reflective of the community, I’m confident The Overlook will become the go-to source for local news, events, the arts, and more.

What’s a story or project from your career that had a lasting impact on you, and how does it shape your vision for The Overlook? 

Scott Widmeyer: Early in my career, I worked as a reporter for a mid-sized daily newspaper. At that time—perhaps even more than today—papers had clear editorial leanings, with some aligning with Democrats and others with Republicans. The paper I worked for leaned Republican, while I was a young Democrat.

Despite this, my editors gave me incredible opportunities, never holding me back from investigative reporting that wasn’t always favorable to Republicans. One of my career highlights came during that period when I covered a sitting Republican governor who was under federal investigation for extortion. I broke several stories about the case, and while the governor was ultimately acquitted, he was later indicted on corruption charges, convicted, and served three years in federal prison.

That experience stayed with me—not just because of the reporting itself, but because of the ethical and fair approach my editors upheld. It reinforced my belief in the importance of rigorous, nonpartisan journalism, which is why that newspaper went on to win multiple awards, including a Pulitzer. That same commitment to integrity, accountability, and fearless reporting is what I bring to The Overlook.

Jacqueline Kellachan: I’m incredibly fortunate to be the co-owner of The Golden Notebook bookstore with James Conrad. Managing and curating this space for over 14 years—engaging daily with people from both the local community and around the world—has been deeply impactful.

Like almost every indie bookstore in the U.S., The Golden Notebook has faced ups and downs. We’ve had to constantly innovate and pivot, listening closely to our customers to figure out what works best from year to year. Keeping a beginner’s mindset has been key, as has adapting to the fluctuations of the local economy and tourism industry. That resilience and flexibility have kept The Golden Notebook thriving—and in many ways, those same principles apply to launching The Overlook. A community-based bookstore starting a community-based newspaper makes more sense than you’d think. Both require deep listening, responsiveness, and a commitment to fostering an engaged and informed public.

What’s a lesson from outside of journalism (life, past careers, hobbies) that you’ve brought into The Overlook?

Jacqueline Kellachan: I’ve worked in public health on and off for about 30 years, primarily in infectious disease epidemiology and maternal and reproductive health. During that time, I’ve had the privilege of working alongside some of the most brilliant, creative, and pragmatic people I’ve ever met—most of them women, by the way.

One of the biggest lessons I’ve learned in public health is that humility, hard work, and playing the long game are always the best approach. I’ve also learned not to be afraid of using radical imagination to break down the barriers and structures that contribute to harm and illness. These same principles have guided me in the planning and launch of The Overlook—staying patient, thinking big, and always keeping the mission at the center of the work.

Scott Widmeyer: The lesson I bring to The Overlook is the importance of transparency—keeping both your door and your mind open. And above all, being grateful. Saying “thank you” to those around you, over and over, is essential.

Equally important is accountability. When you make a mistake, admit it, and apologize. I try my best to live by these values, and on the occasions when I fall short, I remind myself why they matter.

If The Overlook had a theme song, what would it be?  

Jacqueline Kellachan: This has not even crossed my mind. But I am going to say go outside of your house, ideally with a view of Overlook, and listen to John Cage’s “4’33”.”

Scott Widmeyer: Well, there are many songs.  I will offer up three.  They are “Make Your Own Kind of Music” by Cass Elliot,  “Downtown” by Petula Clark, and “We Are Family” by Sister Sledge.


"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Have a tip for a story or an issue in your community? See something happening we should know about? Let us know!

Noah has written for The New York Times, Vogue, Semafor, Variety, The Guardian, Fast Company, and other international, national, and regional outlets. He studied at Columbia University and holds a bachelor's...