Hunter Mayor Alan Higgins, background right, and Village Trustee Jason DiLeo, background left, review documents during a Village Board meeting at the village’s wastewater treatment plant on Sept. 14. Photo by Roy Gumpel/The Overlook.

The Hunter Village Board voted unanimously this week to bring 127 acres in the Town of Hunter into the village so a proposed hotel and housing development could connect to municipal water and sewer. The process, known as annexation, will likely be finalized in December because of an error in the village’s paperwork.

The board passed three resolutions and a local law at its meeting Monday, Nov. 16. The annexation process, which began in June, is the first step in the development of 114 homes, a 45-room hotel, and a 100-seat restaurant and event space proposed by Windham builder Eric Vaughn.

Village officials said the development is expected to go before the village Planning Board next year. 

“He [Vaughn] may or may not be ready for the January meeting,” said Paul Slutzky, chair of the village Planning Board. “We do not, at this point, plan to have a December meeting because of the holidays.”

The development, under the name Four Seasons Hunter, LLC, was formally introduced to the public in June at a joint public hearing between the Town and Village boards. Vaughn sought to bring the property off Scribner Hollow Road into the village to access municipal water and sewer. The vacant lot joins a 14-acre property Vaughn already owns in the village off state Route 23A. 

The Village Board took the lead on the annexation’s environmental review under the State Environmental Quality Review Act and studied the proposal over the summer. In August, it issued a negative declaration, meaning it found the annexation wouldn’t have a significant adverse effect on the environment. The board passed a resolution in October stating its intent to annex the land.

Vaughn said in June that the 72 townhouse units and 42 detached single-family homes planned for the development would be largely geared toward second-home buyers.

Town Supervisor Sean Mahoney said in June that the project was the biggest Hunter had seen in “decades.” Mahoney and the Hunter Town Board later expressed interest in including affordable housing in the development, after locals complained that the town didn’t have enough housing for full-time residents and families.

The three resolutions and the local law don’t mention affordable housing.

Under the village’s zoning law, the property will be partially located in the Gateway Business Zoning District and partially in the Residential Zoning District. Slutzky said Vaughn had initially wanted the entire development to be zoned under the business district.

“The Planning Board and the Village Board felt strongly that the portion closer to 23A where the potential boutique hotel and condominiums or townhouses would be could be in the Gateway Business District, but the single-family homes need to be in the residential district,” he said. “They came back to us with a revised map and changed some of the wording in the resolutions.”

The local law and resolutions passed by the Village Board incorrectly state that the Town Board passed its own resolution in favor of the annexation on Aug. 25. The Town Board didn’t; it tabled its resolution that day to seek more information, Mahoney said this week.

The Town Board still has to pass its resolution for the annexation to move forward, likely at its next meeting on Tuesday, Nov. 24, Mahoney said.

“I’m looking to do it as soon as my attorney gives it the OK,” he said.

After the Town Board passes its resolution, the Village Board will need to repass its local law and resolutions with the correct information, Slutzky said, adding that only then can Village Clerk Kathleen Hilbert formally file the law with the state Department of State.

The Village Board’s next meeting is scheduled for Monday, Dec. 14.

Vaughn didn’t respond to multiple requests for comment this week.

Connor Greco is a staff reporter for The Overlook covering Windham, Hunter, and surrounding Greene County communities. Send correspondence to connor@theoverlooknews.com.


"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Have a tip for a story or an issue in your community? See something happening we should know about? Let us know!

Connor Greco is a lifelong resident of Greene County, graduating from Cairo-Durham High School in 2019. He started his reporting career at the State University of New York at Albany, where he studied journalism...