When we asked readers in October what they wanted more of from The Overlook, the responses were clear: people care deeply about the places they live—and they expect their local digital newspaper to do the same.
Across hundreds of responses, readers voiced a desire for more transparency and accountability in local government. They cited the need for stronger coverage of town boards, planning and zoning board meetings, and alleged misconduct in places like Olive and Woodstock. Others called for deep dives into the politics of Tannersville and county-wide government, and continued scrutiny of development debates like Winston Farm and Zena Homes.
Housing and affordability remain at the center of concern. Respondents described rising prices, gentrification, and the influx of New York City transplants as reshaping their towns. Many want to understand the forces behind the housing shortage, from zoning laws to the proposed lithium-ion battery storage facility.
Environmental issues were top of mind. Readers urged coverage of water contamination, illegal dumping, and climate preparedness, naming the Shady dump and Lower Esopus Creek among specific worries. There’s a clear call for watchdog reporting on how local policies protect or threaten the Catskill Forest Preserve.
At the same time, readers celebrated the very thing that sets The Overlook apart: its hyperlocal focus. Many praised the publication’s independence, high-quality writing, photography, and design, and its ability to capture the character of the Catskills with depth and fairness.
“It’s the first time in years I’ve felt truly informed about what’s happening here. The Overlook makes our towns feel connected again,” one respondent wrote. Another said, “Without The Overlook, a lot of these issues would never see the light of day. It’s the kind of journalism every community deserves.”
Among suggestions: more mountaintop news from Hunter, Windham, and Jewett; expanded arts and community coverage; and a regular calendar of local events. Several readers asked for midweek news alerts, more coverage of the history of each town, and overwhelmingly readers wanted more investigative news and video.
Above all, readers encouraged us to keep going. “Thank you for all you do,” one wrote. “This is exactly what we’ve been missing.”
That encouragement is fuel. As we grow, we’ll keep listening and engaging our community of readers through surveys and listening events. And we’ll keep investigating the stories that matter most to the people who call this region home.
And right now, we have an opportunity to do even more. Through the NewsMatch campaign, every donation made to The Overlook before December 31 will be matched, dollar for dollar, up to $1,000. Your support helps us expand coverage, add reporters, and strengthen independent journalism across the Catskills.
You’ve seen the impact our reporting can make. With your help, we’ll keep it going. Together.
Noah Eckstein is the editor-in-chief of The Overlook. Send correspondence to noah@theoverlooknews.com.
