The Pines, the Mount Tremper restaurant, lodge, and music venue that has become a beloved local gathering place in Shandaken over the past decade, has been listed for sale for $1.3 million.
Owner Jeremy Bernstein said the business, at 5327 state Route 212, will remain open while the property is on the market.
“We’re here business as usual,” Bernstein said. “Please come see us. Come hang out. Let’s make some more memories.”
The listing comes shortly after The Pines marked its 10th anniversary in April. Bernstein, 52, grew up in Woodstock and opened the business after years as a touring musician and woodworker. He bought the former home of Tiso’s Trattoria, restored it, and built a business around food, lodging, live music, outdoor events, and a regular crowd of locals and visitors.
Bernstein said the decision to sell was about closing a chapter and starting a new one, not the result of a business in decline.
“It’s the right time for me,” Bernstein said. “It’s been 10 wonderful years, and all my dreams have come true. Everything that I set out to do at this place has happened.”
He said running The Pines has been all-consuming, especially without partners or investors.
“I’m ready to get a little space back in my life,” Bernstein said. “ I’m ready to kind of just move forward and have this next chapter of my life.”
The real estate listing describes a 3.36-acre property with a 3,300-square-foot building constructed in 1860, five bedrooms, five baths, and waterfront access to the Beaver Kill. The listing also describes five upstairs suites, dining areas, and space for the restaurant operation.
Bernstein said the property and business are being sold together. He said he hopes a future buyer will continue The Pines, though a new owner would ultimately decide how to use the property.
“I would love to see the legacy live on,” Bernstein said. “And a lot of the people that I’m speaking with that are interested in it would like to continue it.”
Interest has already been strong, he said. Within the first several days on the market, Bernstein said, the property had been shown several times, with more visits scheduled.
“So far, everybody is wanting to continue The Pines and continue what we do,” Bernstein said. “And maybe build upon what’s already here.”
For regulars, the listing has brought a mix of nostalgia, nerves, and cautious optimism.
Jamie Buckner, a film producer from Louisville, Ky., who has lived in the area since January 2019, said The Pines quickly became one of his favorite local haunts.
“It’s become kind of our social group,” Buckner said. “It’s our go-to neighborhood spot.”
Buckner said he was “excited for the next chapter” and “nervous what the next step is,” though he said Bernstein’s care for the business gives him confidence.
“Jeremy is who he is, so they’ll find someone who will put as much love into it as he is,” Buckner said.
Bernstein said the memories of the past decade have been flooding back as he talks with customers about the sale.
“There’s been so many magical nights here,” he said. “Just the amount of incredible musicians and music that has passed through these walls is staggering.”
He said the music, friendships, and regulars made the business feel like more than a restaurant.
“I’m super thankful to all of our dedicated patrons who make this place special,” Bernstein said.
Noah Eckstein is the editor-in-chief of The Overlook. Send correspondence to noah@theoverlooknews.com.
