Two horses pulled from a truck that state police said was headed to a Canadian slaughterhouse have a permanent home at Catskill Animal Sanctuary in Saugerties.
The geldings, estimated to be between 11 and 20 years old, arrived Nov. 9, according to the sanctuary. They were among 25 horses seized in September after troopers stopped the truck in St. Lawrence County.
The pair will spend about a month in quarantine at a secondary property before joining the 10 horses at the sanctuary’s main property on Old Stage Road, said Sam Moon, the executive director.
“These two have to be kept separate to make sure they wouldn’t spread anything to the rest of the herd,” said Lauren Hart, the sanctuary’s director of community outreach.
The horses were malnourished when they came into the New York State Humane Association’s care, with ailments that included an abscess, a soft tissue injury, and swelling, the sanctuary said in a news release. Both improved under the association’s care and are expected to make a full recovery, according to the release.
The smaller horse was already running around despite a swollen back foot, staff said. Moon described one of the pair as “spicy.” After finding their way through the barn, the horses spent time along a back fence, Moon said.
Troopers pulled the truck over for a traffic violation on Route 11 in DeKalb on Sept. 2 and found horses tagged for shipment to Canada for slaughter, state police said. The driver was charged under a state law, in effect since 2024, that bars transporting horses for slaughter for human or animal consumption.
The humane association took custody of the horses because law enforcement needed somewhere to put them and people to care for them, said John Scheib, a member of the association’s board.
“They need somebody to take care of the horses while any legal actions are proceeding,” Scheib said.
The association kept the horses at a temporary site in Saratoga County, and some went to rescues and sanctuaries as foster placements. The owner later surrendered the horses, allowing the association to arrange permanent placements, Scheib said.

Before taking the pair, the sanctuary had to weigh staff capacity, funding, grazing space, buildings, and whether it had a place to quarantine them.
“You’re always going to respect your animal care team and their capacity to care for each animal,” Moon said.
The sanctuary cares for about 130 animals across 11 species, including 12 horses, along with cows, pigs, sheep, goats, donkeys, and birds. Sheep are the largest group following a large rescue, and more than 60% of the residents are seniors, Hart said.
“In the winter we’re feeding them way more hay because they’re not grazing, which is a huge piece of their diet,” Hart said.
Veterinary bills, including for unpredictable injuries, are another major expense, Hart said. Those long-term costs help determine whether the sanctuary can take in another animal.
“We have to turn down a lot of animals,” Moon said.
Flooding has also complicated the sanctuary’s work. The New York Times reported in February 2024 that flooding and waterlogged pastures at the sanctuary had eroded soil, damaged trees, and prompted a search for property on higher ground. The article also described the sanctuary’s rescue of 42 neglected sheep, many of whom arrived with anemia and foot rot, a bacterial disease that can worsen in wet conditions.
The sanctuary, founded by Kathy Stevens in 2001, rescues farmed animals from cruelty, neglect, and abandonment and cares for them for life. The nonprofit said it has rescued more than 5,000 animals in 25 years. It also offers tours and educational programs that introduce visitors to the animals and promote vegan living.
The nonprofit also advocates for animal protection laws. The sanctuary said Moon testified in support of Romanch’s Law, which the New York City Council approved Oct. 22 to phase out horse-drawn carriages by June 1, 2028.
Enforcing the state’s ban requires organizations with the space, staff, and money to care for seized animals, Moon said.
“There needs to be enforcement infrastructure and ways to support this law,” Moon said.
Hart said that responsibility repeatedly falls to animal welfare groups.
“That work falls on activists all the time. That work falls on sanctuaries all the time,” she said.
The two geldings will live out their lives at the sanctuary.
“Rescue is only the beginning,” Moon said in the release. “Our responsibility doesn’t end when an animal reaches safety; it continues for as long as they need us.”
Noah Eckstein is the editor-in-chief of The Overlook. Send correspondence to noah@theoverlooknews.com.



